UM "You Pick 2" Tier List

Umphrey's Discussion
202

I can’t put my finger on why but I’ve never been a huge fan of Domino Theory as a composition.

2 Likes
203

Well basically it’s not what it seems

2 Likes
204

You’re way off. Way off.

2 Likes
205

Totally dig domino as a composition so easy A considering it usually gets a jam, even if it’s short

1 Like
206

When I first got into UM back in fall of '11, DBS was one my first UM purchases. I hated Domino Theory at first, and wrote it off as a White Stripes knock-off song. Maybe it’s because of the jam vehicle that it becomes, but I’ve grown an appreciation for Domino Theory over the years, and it’s now one of my favorite UM songs.

207

Completely agree with this. I feel like I like Domino more than most people. It’s a little trashy, sure :slight_smile: But it hits a niche a lot of their other compositions don’t. I also think Domino works better towards the beginning of a set. Ultimately went with C tier though because there aren’t enough standout versions to go higher.

1 Like
208
Song: Eat
  • S
  • A
  • B
  • C
  • D
  • F

0 voters

209
Song: Educated Guess
  • S
  • A
  • B
  • C
  • D
  • F

0 voters

210
Song: End of the Road
  • S
  • A
  • B
  • C
  • D
  • F

0 voters

211

lol @NikoEstevan we disagree a lot on this batch

2 Likes
212

Yah seriously, basically the inverse of each other lol

2 Likes
213

But how do each of you feel about Trump being banned from twitter?

214

LOLOLOLOL

215

Educated Guess for A tier. Something about that song just does it for me.

2 Likes
216

Just got fully caught up with notating every single user’s votes.

Started doing it to determine the biggest fluffers and cynics (per @sabretooth’s suggestion) but I’ll also be giving a shoutout to the frequent voters (we have a lot who have been voting 100% of the time and I appreciate it yall), and those who most frequently aligned with the popular/weighted tiers (and maybe the opposite too). Also might spend some time trying to find everyone an UMfriend, ie the person your votes most align with.

Edit: 30 polls closed, 9 active, and 99 more to go!

5 Likes
217

went back to check if I had 100% and I do.

but I also noticed I was the only one to give Alex’s House S tier. fuck y’all

3 Likes
218

Currently spinning this one to reevaluate - I thought tND “Home” jam was in it but that is in the JaJunk that follows.

1 Like
219

This makes the rest of your votes invalid

1 Like
220

soon it seems I’ll be another face forgotten

1 Like
221

You’ll be in there somewhere