nice, this is a fun one to think about… for me (with the caveat that its all stuff I saw and relistend to a bunch, cant remember other stuff)
In order that they come to mind:
(1) 12/29/2011 St Louis NYE run - BLBC
(2) 02/17/2012 Columbus OH - Wellwishers (JaJunk > WW > JaJunk)
(3) 07/03/2011 Red Rocks - Red Tape bounceback goodness
(4) 04/10/2015 St Augustine FL - The Floor
(5) 12/31/2011 St Louis NYE run - Ocean Billy (this one always felt like quintessential 2011 sound, spacey/dancey monster)
Top 5 ever? For me it’s probably…
5/27/11 Tape (this or 12/11/04 triple wide for textbook bounceback)
10/27/08 Haunt (the untz)
12/3/04 FF (Haunt from this show is also one of their best jazzy jams)
8/26/07 ITK (gets my vote for best encore ever)
4/3/09 Phil’s (attendance bias)