Did a quick search on All Things, and doesn’t appear they have played this song or anything by him.
Weird, I have a very distinct memory of Jake singing it. Mandela Effect!
January 21, 2016Umphrey’s McGee — Beacon Theatre — New York, NY, USA
Set 1: Goonville > Plunger > 40’s Theme, In The Black, Roulette > Kimble, Attachments, Rocker Part 2
Set 2: All In Time[1], Booth Love[2], Bridgeless → Remind Me, Tribute to the Spinal Shaft[3] > Bridgeless
Encore: Space Oddity[4] > Fame
Footnotes:
[1] with The End (The Beatles) tease by Kris
[2] with You Belong to the City (Glenn Frey) jam and quotes
[3] with Xxplosive (Dr. Dre) teases
[4] debut, David Bowie
**Show Notes:**Jake teased YYZ (Rush) before Booth Love
You Belong to the City jam was played in remembrance of Glenn Frey
Space Oddity was played in remembrance of David Bowie
All seriousness, I’m into UM for the same reasons as most, including that their shit is more complex and harder than everything else. That’s what she said. Also, I get what you’re saying, but I’d argue Spafford is Phish heavy in the sense that I’ve always considered them to fall between UM and Phish in terms of heaviness of sound.