When they break into that second verse with the heavier chords 
2 Likes
Meh, almost gave it a B if it wasnt for all the outstanding versions. Boring set eater these days imo.
4 Likes
I’d say the opposite. Billy has been generally way more consistent over the years
5 Likes
Billy and Fancy are both A’s to me. Agree that Fancy once was an S. Composition is too damn good for me to knock it down below A though. I still listen to Jake’s solo every time when I skim through shows with Fancy in them.
2 Likes
Kinda hate OB. Feels like it’s building the whole time but never really gets anywhere. (Inb4 somebody calls it a quintessential UM song). Good jams are the only reason it gets a C for me.
1 Like
Love to hear it. Fully agree.
3 Likes
Song Out of Order
- S
- A
- B
- C
- D
- F
0 voters
Song: Padgett’s Profile
- S
- A
- B
- C
- D
- F
0 voters
Song: Partyin’ Peeps
- S
- A
- B
- C
- D
- F
0 voters
OoO is the easiest S I’ve ever given, I’d take that song every show
7 Likes
5 Likes
Absolutely love OoO
6 Likes
One of my first memories of the the bort, maybe 2008? Was seeing OoO notated on setlists and having no idea what it meant.
4 Likes
Another obligatory appreciation for @NikoEstevan taking charge of this.
6 Likes
Top tier landing pad song after a dark and spooky jam. Pop that in the slot just before set break chef’s kiss
Peeps gets a lot of hate here. I actually dig it as well. Fun, silly song, and the end peak is tight.
3 Likes
the end peak is like the ending credits for an epic 80s movie.
1 Like
I really can’t be any meaner to Peeps than a C. The peak is too good, and I begrudgingly admit it’s an important casual fan song in their discography. Many a beeline for the toilet has been taken during it though 
OOO is one of two “standard-only” songs that gets an S from me. Perfect composition. Ecstatic to have a studio version of it now too.
2 Likes
Me leaving that show:
10 Likes