UM "You Pick 2" Tier List

@NikoEstevan Do you have a list of all the songs so far? Would love to retroactively vote, but don’t want to dig through the thread for them all.

2 Likes

I love Nemo.

2 Likes

Blows my mind that Mulche’s isn’t all S or A. It’s the song that hooked me.

1 Like

He sent me the list a while back. I haven’t voted yet. Been meaning to do that. Its def a thing

1 Like

Same. First UM song I listened to and immediately learned it on guitar. I was 15 and it took me months. I must’ve watched that YT video of the live Mulches a thousand times.

Btw, idc what they say. The song is called Mulches not Mulshays

Bridgeless was the first song I saw live and thats what reeeeally hooked me I guess. For all the shit we talk, these boys really are good. If they could only do what I want them to do all the time…

3 Likes

Tinkles > Mulche’s from the NYE 2004 DVD is one of the things that got me into UM.

Mulche’s gets standard dub jams a lot but the ending is quintessential UM. And when you get that super rare fake/double ending (10/29/10 and 6/28/15 for example) …chef’s kiss

2 Likes

Agreed, I don’t care how the band pronounces it, in my mind it’ll always be the chucks of bark covered in animal shit you throw in your garden for fertilizer

1 Like

I got you fam, everyone is allowed to vote on closed polls (or change their vote). I’ll PM you the closed polls you’ve missed

2 Likes

Please make public any embarrassing vote changes. We need to know who our S-tier Whistle Kids fanbois are.

1 Like

Nemo has one of my favorite UM lyrics.

And everytime we seem aware of all that matters
there will always be a memory you forget.

1 Like

Dude thanks a bunch. Really cool concept, appreciate all the work and thought you put into the scoring.

2 Likes

Please let me as well, thank you sir

1 Like

8/9/2014 also has that double ending. Also, the precomposed stew is berry purdy, solid for a 4 min jam

Nemo is right on the A/B line for me. Inconsistency is the issue. That being said, it always brings a smile to my face to catch the composed part live no matter what they end up doing with it, so maybe after some consideration I’ll bump it back up. I’ll think about it :slight_smile:

I want Mulche’s to be A tier really badly but the jam is the same 90% of the time and unfortunately that’s a net negative for me hearing it at shows as well. What a composition though!

2 Likes

Such a great composition. I love that lasers vid up on youtube, def give that a spin from time to time. Freakin’ lasers, maaaan:

https://rb.gy/px4ncg

May I get the link to vote for closed polls too pls

1 Like

I’ll PM you two later today @sociablehodor and @ian

2 Likes

No. Those who didn’t put the work in from the beginning shouldn’t get handouts now!!

Wait, is this the student loan thread?

7 Likes
Song: Night Nurse
  • S
  • A
  • B
  • C
  • D
  • F

0 voters

Song: No Diablo
  • S
  • A
  • B
  • C
  • D
  • F

0 voters